A Google Manual Penalty, also known as a Manual Action, is issued when a human reviewer at Google determines that pages on your site violate Google's Webmaster Guidelines. Unlike algorithmic devaluations (which are automated and often less transparent), a manual penalty is a direct consequence of detectable manipulative practices. These penalties can severely impact your site's rankings or even lead to its complete removal from Google's search results.
Identifying and fixing the issues causing a manual penalty is crucial for recovering your search visibility.
What is a Google Manual Penalty and Why Does it Happen?
A manual penalty is a specific action taken by a Google spam reviewer. They occur when your site is found to be engaging in practices intended to manipulate Google's search index in ways that violate their guidelines. This could include deceptive tactics or artificial attempts to inflate rankings.
If your site receives a manual action, Google will notify you directly in your Google Search Console account and usually via email.
Common Types of Google Manual Actions
Manual actions are issued for various violations. Some of the most common types include:
Unnatural links to your site: This is a frequent penalty, issued when Google detects artificial, manipulative, or deceptive links pointing to your website (e.g., bought links, excessive link exchanges, large-scale article marketing or guest posting schemes solely for links).
Unnatural links from your site: Issued when your site contains artificial, manipulative, or deceptive outbound links (e.g., selling PageRank-passing links).
Thin content with little or no added value: Pages with minimal original content, such as scraped content, doorway pages designed purely to funnel users to another page, or automatically generated content lacking substance.
Pure spam: Sites using aggressive spam techniques, including automatically generated content, cloaking, scraping, or other blatant violations.
User-generated spam: Spammy content added to your site by users (e.g., forum spam, spammy comments).
Cloaking and/or sneaky redirects: Showing different content to users than to Googlebot, or redirecting users to unexpected pages.
Hidden text and/or keyword stuffing: Hiding text or links from users (e.g., white text on a white background) or excessively repeating keywords in a way that harms user experience.
Hacked site: Your site has been compromised, and spammy content or links have been added by a hacker.
How to Check for a Google Manual Penalty
Google's primary method of notifying you of a manual penalty is through Google Search Console (GSC):
Log in to Google Search Console: Go to search.google.com/search-console and select the property (website) that you manage.
Navigate to "Manual actions": In the left-hand navigation menu, find and click on Security & Manual actions > Manual actions.
Check the report:
If you see "No webspam manual actions found," your site does not currently have a manual penalty.
If your site has a manual action, you will see a message detailing the type of penalty, the affected pages (site-wide or specific URLs/sections), and a brief explanation of the issue.
You should also check your email associated with your GSC account, as Google usually sends an email notification as well.
How to Identify and Fix Issues Causing a Manual Penalty
The process for fixing a manual penalty involves identifying all instances of the violating practice, rectifying them, and then informing Google of the steps you've taken.
General Steps for Any Manual Action:
Don't Panic & Understand the Penalty: Read the manual action notification in GSC carefully. Understand the specific type of violation and whether it affects the entire site or just parts of it. Google often provides example URLs, but remember these are just examples, not an exhaustive list.
Identify ALL Instances of the Violation: This is the most time-consuming step. You need to conduct a thorough audit to find every single page, link, or element on your site related to the manual action.
Rectify the Issues: Fix or remove all identified instances of the violation according to Google's guidelines.
Document Your Work: Keep a detailed record of the steps you took to identify and fix the issues. This documentation is crucial for your reconsideration request.
Submit a Reconsideration Request: Once you are confident that you have fixed all the issues, submit a request to Google via the Manual actions report in GSC.
Wait for Review: A Google reviewer will examine your site and the documentation of your fixes. This process can take several days to a few weeks. You will be notified of the outcome in GSC. If the request is denied, you'll usually receive feedback on what issues still need to be addressed, and you can submit another request after making further improvements.
Specific Steps for Common Manual Actions:
Here's how to approach fixing some frequent manual penalty types:
1. Unnatural links to your site:
Identify unnatural links:
Use the Links report in GSC ("Top linking sites" and "Top linked pages").
Use third-party backlink analysis tools (Ahrefs, Semrush, Moz, Majestic) to get a comprehensive list of backlinks.
Review your backlinks manually or using tool features to identify links that appear unnatural, low-quality, irrelevant, or acquired through manipulative means (e.g., links from spammy directories, unrelated sites, sites with excessive outbound links, links with overly optimized anchor text that look unnatural).
Attempt to remove the links:
Prioritize removing the most clearly unnatural or harmful links first.
Contact the webmasters of the linking sites and politely request the removal of the specific link. Keep a record of your outreach efforts (date, contact method, response).
Use the Disavow Tool (as a last resort):
For links you cannot get removed, compile a list of these links (URLs or domains) in a plain text file formatted according to Google's guidelines.
Submit this file using the Google Disavow tool (search.google.com/search-console/disavow-links). Only disavow links you are certain are unnatural and that you could not get removed.
In Reconsideration Request: Detail your efforts to remove links (including documentation of outreach) and list the links you disavowed.
2. Thin content with little or no added value:
Identify thin content:
Review pages flagged in the manual action notification.
Audit your site for pages with minimal text, automatically generated content, scraped content copied from other sites, doorway pages, or pages with very little unique value for users.
Rectify the issues:
For valuable but thin pages: Significantly expand and improve the content to make it comprehensive, unique, and helpful to users. Add unique insights, data, images, or other elements that provide real value.
For low-value or duplicate pages: If the content is duplicate or provides no unique value and cannot be significantly improved, consider removing the page and implementing a 301 redirect to a relevant, higher-quality page, or simply deleting it if there's no suitable redirect target.
Ensure any automatically generated content is reviewed, edited, and significantly enhanced by a human to provide unique value.
If content is scraped, remove it entirely.
In Reconsideration Request: Explain how you've improved or removed the thin content, providing examples of pages you've fixed and pages you've removed or consolidated.
3. Pure spam:
This penalty often applies to sites with multiple aggressive spam violations.
You need to identify and rectify all the spammy tactics used (scaled content, cloaking, scraping, etc.) based on the specific type of spam indicated or detected.
This often requires a complete overhaul of the site's approach and content strategy.
In Reconsideration Request: Be transparent about the spammy practices used and provide clear, detailed evidence of how all instances of the violations have been removed or corrected across the entire site.
4. Other penalties (e.g., User-generated spam, Cloaking, Hacked site):
Address the specific issue highlighted in the GSC notification.
For user-generated spam, clean up all spammy content and implement measures to prevent future spam (e.g., stronger moderation, CAPTCHAs).
For cloaking, ensure the content shown to users and Googlebot is the same.
For a hacked site, secure your site, remove the hacked content, and identify/fix the vulnerability. GSC's Security Issues report provides details for hacked sites.
Submitting a Reconsideration Request
Once you have thoroughly identified and fixed all issues mentioned in the manual action notice (and any other related guideline violations you find), you must submit a reconsideration request through Google Search Console:
Go to the Manual actions report in GSC.
Click the Request Review button.
Provide a detailed explanation of:
The type of manual action received.
The specific steps you took to identify and fix all the issues.
Any documentation of your work (e.g., lists of removed links, examples of improved content).
Your plan to prevent these issues from happening again in the future.
Submit the request.
Google will review your request and notify you of the outcome in GSC. If your request is approved, the manual action will be removed, and your site will be eligible to rank normally again (though it may take time to regain its previous rankings). If denied, you must make further improvements based on their feedback and submit another request.
Preventing Future Penalties
The best way to handle manual penalties is to avoid them in the first place. Adhere strictly to Google's Webmaster Guidelines, focusing on building a high-quality, user-centric website with original, valuable content and earning natural backlinks through merit. Regularly audit your site for potential issues before they trigger a manual action.
Identifying and fixing a Google manual penalty is a challenging but necessary process for restoring your site's health and search visibility. By carefully diagnosing the problem, thoroughly rectifying all violations, and clearly communicating your efforts to Google, you can work towards recovery.
Tired of wading through complex data to figure out your internal linking strategy or other technical SEO tasks? Focus on the key insights you need without overwhelming data overload. Experience a clutter-free way to manage and optimize your site's structure and links. Discover the advantage of a simple and distraction-free interface with seochatbot.ai.
